Topic 9

Implicit Differentiation

When xx and yy are tangled in one equation, differentiate both sides with respect to xx and treat yy as a function of xx: every yy-term picks up a factor y′y' by the chain rule. Then it is algebra — collect the y′y' terms, factor, divide.

4 kinds of question. Open the one you are stuck on.

1

Find dy/dx by implicit differentiation

e.g. “Variables xx and yy are related by the equation … Find dydx\dfrac{dy}{dx}”
  1. 1
    Differentiate both sides with respect to xx

    Term by term, left and right. A constant on either side becomes 00.

  2. 2
    Every yy-term gets a factor y′y' (chain rule)

    (y3)′=3y2y′(y^3)' = 3y^2y', (sin⁡y)′=cos⁡y y′(\sin y)' = \cos y\,y', (7y)′=7ylog⁡7 y′(7^{y})' = 7^{y}\log 7\,y'. A product such as xyxy needs the product rule: y+xy′y + xy'.

  3. 3
    Move every y′y' term to one side, the rest to the other
  4. 4
    Factor out y′y' and divide

Remember: Differentiate, tag every yy with y′y', collect, divide.

See it in a problem4 worked examples

Find dydx\dfrac{dy}{dx} if x2+3xy−y3=9x^2 + 3xy - y^3 = 9.

  1. 1
    Differentiate both sides with respect to xx

    2x+3(y+xy′)−3y2y′=02x + 3(y + xy') - 3y^2y' = 0.

  2. 2
    Every yy-term gets a factor y′y' (chain rule)

    3xy3xy used the product rule (y+xy′y + xy'); y3y^3 became 3y2y′3y^2y'.

  3. 3
    Move every y′y' term to one side, the rest to the other

    3xy′−3y2y′=−2x−3y3xy' - 3y^2y' = -2x - 3y.

  4. 4
    Factor out y′y' and divide

    y′(3x−3y2)=−2x−3yy'(3x - 3y^2) = -2x - 3y, so y′=−2x−3y3x−3y2=2x+3y3y2−3xy' = \dfrac{-2x - 3y}{3x - 3y^2} = \dfrac{2x + 3y}{3y^2 - 3x}.

Answer:

dydx=2x+3y3y2−3x\dfrac{dy}{dx} = \dfrac{2x + 3y}{3y^2 - 3x}

Common mistakes4
  • Writing ddxy2=2y\dfrac{d}{dx}y^2 = 2y. It is 2y y′2y\,y': yy depends on xx.
  • Differentiating xyxy as y′y' or as 1⋅y′1 \cdot y'. It is a product: y+xy′y + xy'.
  • Forgetting the inside of a composite: ddxsin⁡(x+y)=cos⁡(x+y) (1+y′)\dfrac{d}{dx}\sin(x + y) = \cos(x + y)\,(1 + y').
  • Dividing before every y′y' term is on one side — you end up with y′y' on both sides of the answer.
2

Find the tangent line to an implicit curve

e.g. “Find the equation of the tangent line to the curve F(x,y)=cF(x, y) = c at the point (a,b)(a, b)”
  1. 1
    Check the point is on the curve

    Plug it into the original equation. If only x=ax = a is given, plug that in and solve for yy to get the point.

  2. 2
    Differentiate both sides implicitly
  3. 3
    Plug in the point right away, then solve for y′y'

    Allowed: the differentiated equation holds at every point of the curve, so substitute before solving. The algebra becomes a one-line linear equation in y′y'.

  4. 4
    Write y−b=m(x−a)y - b = m(x - a)

Remember: Check, differentiate, plug in early, line.

See it in a problem3 worked examples

Find the tangent line to x2+xy+y3=11x^2 + xy + y^3 = 11 at the point (1,2)(1, 2).

  1. 1
    Check the point is on the curve

    1+2+8=111 + 2 + 8 = 11. On the curve.

  2. 2
    Differentiate both sides implicitly

    2x+y+xy′+3y2y′=02x + y + xy' + 3y^2y' = 0.

  3. 3
    Plug in the point right away, then solve for y′y'

    At (1,2)(1, 2): 2+2+y′+12y′=0⇒13y′=−4⇒m=−4132 + 2 + y' + 12y' = 0 \Rightarrow 13y' = -4 \Rightarrow m = -\dfrac{4}{13}.

  4. 4
    Write y−b=m(x−a)y - b = m(x - a)

    y−2=−413(x−1)y - 2 = -\dfrac{4}{13}(x - 1).

Answer:

y−2=−413(x−1)y - 2 = -\dfrac{4}{13}(x - 1)

Common mistakes3
  • Plugging the point into the curve and differentiating the result. Differentiate first, then substitute.
  • Mixing up which coordinate goes where: x=ax = a and y=by = b in every term, including inside y2y^2 and xyxy.
  • If substituting gives 0⋅y′=nonzero0 \cdot y' = \text{nonzero}, the tangent is vertical: write x=ax = a.
3

Find horizontal and vertical tangents on an implicit curve

e.g. “At which points on the curve is the tangent line horizontal?”
  1. 1
    Find y′=NDy' = \dfrac{N}{D} implicitly
  2. 2
    Horizontal: solve N=0N = 0 together with the curve

    Use N=0N = 0 to express one variable in terms of the other, then substitute into the curve's equation.

  3. 3
    Vertical: solve D=0D = 0 together with the curve
  4. 4
    Check the other part is not 00 there

    At a horizontal point D≠0D \neq 0; at a vertical point N≠0N \neq 0. If both are 00, this test says nothing. Discard non-real solutions.

  5. 5
    Write y=by = b or x=ax = a for each point

Remember: Top zero: flat. Bottom zero: vertical. Always back into the curve.

See it in a problem2 worked examples

Find all points on x2+xy+y2=12x^2 + xy + y^2 = 12 where the tangent line is horizontal or vertical.

  1. 1
    Find y′=NDy' = \dfrac{N}{D} implicitly

    2x+y+xy′+2yy′=0⇒y′=−2x+yx+2y2x + y + xy' + 2yy' = 0 \Rightarrow y' = -\dfrac{2x + y}{x + 2y}. So N=2x+yN = 2x + y, D=x+2yD = x + 2y.

  2. 2
    Horizontal: solve N=0N = 0 together with the curve

    N=0N = 0: y=−2xy = -2x. Then x2−2x2+4x2=3x2=12x^2 - 2x^2 + 4x^2 = 3x^2 = 12, so x=±2x = \pm 2: points (2,−4)(2, -4) and (−2,4)(-2, 4).

  3. 3
    Vertical: solve D=0D = 0 together with the curve

    D=0D = 0: x=−2yx = -2y. Then 4y2−2y2+y2=3y2=124y^2 - 2y^2 + y^2 = 3y^2 = 12, so y=±2y = \pm 2: points (−4,2)(-4, 2) and (4,−2)(4, -2).

  4. 4
    Check the other part is not 00 there

    DD at (2,−4)(2, -4) is −6-6, at (−2,4)(-2, 4) is 66. NN at (−4,2)(-4, 2) is −6-6, at (4,−2)(4, -2) is 66. None are 00.

  5. 5
    Write y=by = b or x=ax = a for each point

    Horizontal: y=−4y = -4 and y=4y = 4. Vertical: x=−4x = -4 and x=4x = 4.

Answer:

Horizontal at (2,−4)(2, -4), (−2,4)(-2, 4); vertical at (−4,2)(-4, 2), (4,−2)(4, -2)

Common mistakes3
  • Solving N=0N = 0 alone. Points must lie on the curve, so solve N=0N = 0 and the curve's equation together.
  • Mixing them up: a vertical tangent has undefined slope, so it is the denominator that vanishes.
  • Keeping an xx-value that gives no real yy (a negative discriminant): there is no point there.
4

Find the second derivative implicitly

e.g. “Find d2ydx2\dfrac{d^2y}{dx^2} for the curve …”
  1. 1
    Find y′y' implicitly
  2. 2
    Differentiate y′y' again; each yy gets a y′y'

    Usually the quotient rule. Treat yy exactly as in the first pass.

  3. 3
    Substitute the formula for y′y'

    At a point: just plug in the numbers for xx, yy and y′y'.

  4. 4
    Simplify, using the curve's equation where it appears

    A combination such as x2+4y2x^2 + 4y^2 that matches the curve can be replaced by its constant.

Remember: Differentiate twice, then kill the y′y'.

See it in a problem3 worked examples

Find y′′y'' in terms of yy only for the ellipse x2+4y2=16x^2 + 4y^2 = 16.

  1. 1
    Find y′y' implicitly

    2x+8yy′=0⇒y′=−x4y2x + 8yy' = 0 \Rightarrow y' = -\dfrac{x}{4y}.

  2. 2
    Differentiate y′y' again; each yy gets a y′y'

    y′′=−(1)(4y)−x(4y′)16y2=−y−xy′4y2y'' = -\dfrac{(1)(4y) - x(4y')}{16y^2} = -\dfrac{y - xy'}{4y^2}.

  3. 3
    Substitute the formula for y′y'

    y−x(−x4y)=4y2+x24yy - x\left(-\dfrac{x}{4y}\right) = \dfrac{4y^2 + x^2}{4y}, so y′′=−x2+4y216y3y'' = -\dfrac{x^2 + 4y^2}{16y^3}.

  4. 4
    Simplify, using the curve's equation where it appears

    On the curve x2+4y2=16x^2 + 4y^2 = 16: y′′=−1616y3=−1y3y'' = -\dfrac{16}{16y^3} = -\dfrac{1}{y^3}.

Answer:

y′′=−1y3y'' = -\dfrac{1}{y^3}

Common mistakes3
  • Treating yy as a constant in the second pass: ddx(xy)=y−xy′y2\dfrac{d}{dx}\left(\dfrac{x}{y}\right) = \dfrac{y - xy'}{y^2}, not 1y\dfrac{1}{y}.
  • Leaving y′y' in the final answer when the question wants xx and yy only.
  • Not spotting the curve's equation inside the numerator — the simplification that makes the answer short.

Need the formulas? Must memorize · Flashcards

Found this helpful? Leave us a review on Google ↗Spotted a mistake?

Which topics are you reviewing?

The topic list, Flashcards, Must memorize and Exam words will only show these. Change it any time with the Topics button above the topic list.

Limits & continuity
Derivatives
Applications
Theorems & approximation
10 of 17 topics selected