Navigation

Geometry in three dimensions

14.3 (optional) Sketching surfaces in 3D

10 problems · hints, answers and solutions shown beside each one

Stage 1 · Conceptual

Q1Stage 1Past exam · M200 2008A

Match the following equations and expressions with the corresponding pictures.

(A)

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 19

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 19

(B)

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 19

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 19

(C)

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 19

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 19

(a)x2+y2=z2+1(b)y=x2+z2(c)z=x4+y44xy\begin{alignat*}{7} &\text{(a)}\quad& x^2+y^2&=z^2+1 &\qquad \text{(b)} \quad& y&=x^2+z^2\qquad & & \text{(c)}\quad& z&=x^4+y^4-4xy & \end{alignat*}
Hint

Consider the traces. That is, if you set one variable equal to a constant, what will the resulting cross-sections look like?

Answer

(a) \leftrightarrow (B) (b) \leftrightarrow (A) (c) \leftrightarrow (C)

Full solution

(a) Each constant zz cross–section of x2+y2=z2+1x^2+y^2=z^2+1 is a (horizontal) circle centred on the zz–axis. The radius of the circle is 11 when z=0z=0 and grows as zz moves away from z=0z=0. So x2+y2=z2+1x^2+y^2=z^2+1 consists of a bunch of (horizontal) circles stacked on top of each other, with the radius increasing with z|z|. It is a hyperboloid of one sheet. The picture that corresponds to (a) is (B).

(b) Every point of y=x2+z2y=x^2+z^2 has y0y\ge 0. Only (A) has that property. We can also observe that every constant yy cross–section is a circle centred on x=z=0x=z=0. The radius of the circle is zero when y=0y=0 and increases as yy increases. The surface y=x2+z2y=x^2+z^2 is a paraboloid. The picture that corresponds to (b) is (A).

(c) The only possibility left is that the picture that corresponds to (c) is (C).

Q2Stage 1

Sketch a few level curves for the function f(x,y)f(x,y) whose graph z=f(x,y)z=f(x,y) is sketched below.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 156

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 156

Hint

Draw in the plane z=Cz=C for several values of CC.

Answer

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 169

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 169

Full solution

We first add into the sketch of the graph the horizontal planes z=Cz=C, for C=3C=3, 22, 11, 0.50.5, 0.250.25.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 176

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 176

To reduce clutter, for each CC, we have drawn in only

  • the (gray) intersection of the horizontal plane z=Cz=C with the yzyz–plane, i.e. with the vertical plane x=0x=0, and

  • the (blue) intersection of the horizontal plane z=Cz=C with the graph z=f(x,y)z=f(x,y).

We have also omitted the label for the plane z=0.25z=0.25.

The intersection of the plane z=Cz=C with the graph z=f(x,y)z=f(x,y) is line

{ (x,y,z)  z=f(x,y), z=C }={ (x,y,z)  f(x,y)=C, z=C }\begin{equation*} \Set{(x,y,z)}{z=f(x,y),\ z=C} = \Set{(x,y,z)}{f(x,y)=C,\ z=C} \end{equation*}

Drawing this line (which is parallel to the xx-axis) in the xyxy-plane, rather than in the plane z=Cz=C, gives a level curve. Doing this for each of C=3C=3, 22, 11, 0.50.5, 0.250.25 gives five level curves.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 169

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 169

Stage 2 · Procedural

Q3Stage 2

Sketch some of the level curves of

  1. f(x,y)=x2+2y2f(x,y)=x^2+2y^2

  2. f(x,y)=xyf(x,y)=xy

  3. f(x,y)=xeyf(x,y)=xe^{-y}

Hint

Remember when you set f(x,y)f(x,y) equal to a constant, the result is a curve with only xx's and yy's.

Answer

(a)

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 227

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 227

(b)

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 227

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 227

(c)

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 227

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 227

Full solution

(a) For each fixed c>0c>0, the level curve x2+2y2=cx^2+2y^2=c is the ellipse centred on the origin with xx semi axis c\sqrt{c} and yy semi axis c/2\sqrt{c/2}. If c=0c=0, the level curve x2+2y2=c=0x^2+2y^2=c=0 is the single point (0,0)(0,0).

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 227

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 227

(b) For each fixed c0c\ne 0, the level curve xy=cxy=c is a hyperbola centred on the origin with asymptotes the xx- and yy-axes. If c>0c>0, any xx and yy obeying xy=c>0xy=c>0 are of the same sign. So the hyperbola is contained in the first and third quadrants. If c<0c<0, any xx and yy obeying xy=c>0xy=c>0 are of opposite sign. So the hyperbola is contained in the second and fourth quadrants. If c=0c=0, the level curve xy=c=0xy=c=0 is the single point (0,0)(0,0).

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 227

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 227

(c) For each fixed c0c\ne 0, the level curve xey=cxe^{-y}=c is the logarithmic curve y=lncxy=-\ln\frac{c}{x}. Note that, for c>0c>0, the curve

  • is restricted to x>0x>0, so that cx>0\frac{c}{x}>0 and lncx\ln \frac{c}{x} is defined, and that

  • as x0+x\rightarrow 0^+, yy goes to -\infty, while

  • as x+x\rightarrow +\infty, yy goes to ++\infty, and

  • the curve crosses the xx-axis (i.e. has y=0y=0) when x=cx=c.

and for c<0c<0, the curve

  • is restricted to x<0x<0, so that cx>0\frac{c}{x}>0 and lncx\ln \frac{c}{x} is defined, and that

  • as x0x\rightarrow 0^-, yy goes to -\infty, while

  • as xx\rightarrow -\infty, yy goes to ++\infty, and

  • the curve crosses the xx-axis (i.e. has y=0y=0) when x=cx=c.

If c=0c=0, the level curve xey=c=0xe^{-y}=c=0 is the yy-axis, x=0x=0.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 227

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 227

Q4Stage 2Past exam · M200 2010D

Sketch the level curves of f(x,y)=2yx2+y2f(x,y)=\frac{2y}{x^2+y^2}.

Hint

The circle centred at (0,a)(0,a) with radius rr has equation

x2+(ya)2=r2x^2+(y-a)^2=r^2

Rearranged, this is

x2+y2(2a)y=r2=a2x^2+y^2-(2a)y=r^2=a^2

Use this to describe the level curves of the function given.

Answer

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 2

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 2

Full solution

If C=0C=0, the level curve f=C=0f=C=0 is just the line y=0y=0. If C0C\ne 0 (of either sign), we may rewrite the equation, f(x,y)=2yx2+y2=Cf(x,y)=\frac{2y}{x^2+y^2}=C, of the level curve f=Cf=C as

x22Cy+y2=0    x2+(y1C)2=1C2\begin{equation*} x^2-\frac{2}{C}y+y^2=0 \iff x^2+\left(y-\frac{1}{C}\right)^2 =\frac{1}{C^2} \end{equation*}

which is the equation of the circle of radius 1C\frac{1}{|C|} centred on (0,1C)\left(0\,,\,\frac{1}{C}\right).

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 2

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 2

Remark.
To be picky, the function f(x,y)=2yx2+y2f(x,y)=\frac{2y}{x^2+y^2} is not defined at (x,y)=(0,0)(x,y)=(0,0). The question should have either specified that the domain of ff excludes (0,0)(0,0) or have specified a value for f(0,0)f(0,0). In fact, it is impossible to assign a value to f(0,0)f(0,0) in such a way that f(x,y)f(x,y) is continuous at (0,0)(0,0), because limx0f(x,0)=0\lim_{x\rightarrow 0}f(x,0)=0 while limy0f(0,y)=\lim_{y\rightarrow 0}f(0,|y|)=\infty. So it makes more sense to have the domain of ff being R2\bbbr^2
with the point (0,0)(0,0) removed. That's why there is a little hole at the origin in the above sketch.

Q5Stage 2Past exam · M253 2011D

A surface is given implicitly by

x2+y2z2+2z=0\begin{equation*} x^2 + y^2 - z^2 + 2z = 0 \end{equation*}
  1. Sketch several level curves z=z =constant.

  2. Draw a rough sketch of the surface.

Hint

If zz is constant, then the entire expression z2+2z-z^2+2z is one big constant.

Answer

(a)

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 424

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 424

(b)

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 424

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 424

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 424

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 424

Full solution

(a) We can rewrite the equation as

x2+y2=(z1)21\begin{equation*} x^2 + y^2 = (z-1)^2 - 1 \end{equation*}

The right hand side is negative for z1<1|z-1|<1, i.e. for 0<z<20<z<2. So no point on the surface has 0<z<20<z<2. For any fixed zz, outside that range, the curve x2+y2=(z1)21x^2 + y^2 = (z-1)^2 - 1 is the circle of radius (z1)21\sqrt{(z-1)^2 - 1} centred on the zz–axis. That radius is 00 when z=0,2z=0,2 and increases as zz moves away from z=0,2z=0,2. For very large z|z|, the radius increases roughly linearly with z|z|. Here is a sketch of some level curves.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 424

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 424

(b) The surface consists of two stacks of circles. One stack starts with radius 00 at z=2z=2. The radius increases as zz increases. The other stack starts with radius 00 at z=0z=0. The radius increases as zz decreases. This surface is a hyperboloid of two sheets. Here are two sketchs. The sketch on the left is of the part of the surface in the first octant. The sketch on the right of the full surface.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 424

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 424

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 424

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 424

Q6Stage 2Past exam · M226 2009A

Sketch the hyperboloid z2=4x2+y21z^2=4x^2+y^2-1.

Hint

For each fixed zz, 4x2+y2=1+z24x^2+y^2=1+z^2 is an ellipse. So the surface consists of a stack of ellipses one on top of the other. The

Answer

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 483

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 483

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 483

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 483

Full solution

For each fixed zz, 4x2+y2=1+z24x^2+y^2=1+z^2 is an ellipse. So the surface consists of a stack of ellipses one on top of the other. The semi axes are 121+z2\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{1+z^2} and 1+z2\sqrt{1+z^2}. These are smallest when z=0z=0 (i.e. for the ellipse in the xyxy-plane) and increase as z|z| increases. The intersection of the surface with the xzxz-plane (i.e. with the plane y=0y=0) is the hyperbola 4x2z2=14x^2-z^2=1 and the intersection with the yzyz-pane (i.e. with the plane x=0x=0) is the hyperbola y2z2=1y^2-z^2=1. Here are two sketches of the surface. The sketch on the left only shows the part of the surface in the first octant (with axes).

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 483

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 483

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 483

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 483

Q7Stage 2

Sketch the graphs of

  1. f(x,y)=sinx0x2π, 0y1f(x,y)=\sin x\qquad 0\le x\le 2\pi,\ 0\le y\le 1

  2. f(x,y)=x2+y2f(x,y)=\sqrt{x^2+y^2}

  3. f(x,y)=x+yf(x,y)=|x|+|y|

Hint

Start by determining what convenient traces look like. For (a), the level curves are less instructive at first than are the traces found by setting yy equal to a constant.

Answer

(a)

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 572

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 572

(b)

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 572

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 572

(c)

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 572

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 572

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 572

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 572

Full solution

(a) The graph is z=sinxz=\sin x with (x,y)(x,y) running over 0x2π0\le x\le 2\pi, 0y10\le y\le 1. For each fixed y0y_0 between 00 and 11, the intersection of this graph with the vertical plane y=y0y=y_0 is the same sin graph z=sinxz=\sin x with xx running from 00 to 2π2\pi. So the whole graph is just a bunch of 2-d sin graphs stacked side-by-side. This gives the graph on the left below.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 590

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 590

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 590

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 590

(b) The graph is z=x2+y2z=\sqrt{x^2+y^2}. For each fixed z00z_0\ge 0, the intersection of this graph with the horizontal plane z=z0z=z_0 is the circle x2+y2=z0\sqrt{x^2+y^2}=z_0. This circle is centred on the zz-axis and has radius z0z_0. So the graph is the upper half of a cone. It is the sketch on the right above.

(c) The graph is z=x+yz=|x|+|y|. For each fixed z00z_0\ge 0, the intersection of this graph with the horizontal plane z=z0z=z_0 is the square x+y=z0|x|+|y|=z_0. The side of the square with x,y0x,y\ge 0 is the straight line x+y=z0x+y=z_0. The side of the square with x0x\ge 0 and y0y\le 0 is the straight line xy=z0x-y=z_0 and so on. The four corners of the square are (±z0,0,z0)(\pm z_0,0,z_0) and (0,±z0,z0)(0, \pm z_0,z_0). So the graph is a stack of squares. It is an upside down four-sided pyramid. The part of the pyramid in the first octant (that is, x,y,z0x,y,z\ge 0) is the sketch below.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 572

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 572

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 572

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 572

Q8Stage 2

Sketch and describe the following surfaces.

  1. 4x2+y2=164x^2+y^2=16

  2. x+y+2z=4x+y+2z=4

  3. y29+z24=1+x216\frac{y^2}{9}+\frac{z^2}{4}=1+\frac{x^2}{16}

  4. y2=x2+z2y^2=x^2+z^2

  5. x29+y212+z29=1\frac{x^2}{9}+\frac{y^2}{12}+\frac{z^2}{9}=1

  6. x2+y2+z2+4xby+9zb=0x^2+y^2+z^2+4x-by+9z-b=0 where bb is a constant.

  7. x4=y24+z29\frac{x}{4}=\frac{y^2}{4}+\frac{z^2}{9}

  8. z=x2z=x^2

Answer

(a) This is an elliptic cylinder parallel to the zz-axis. Here is a sketch of the part of the surface above the xyxy–plane.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

(b) This is a plane through (4,0,0)(4,0,0), (0,4,0)(0,4,0) and (0,0,2)(0,0,2). Here is a sketch of the part of the plane in the first octant.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

(c) This is a hyperboloid of one sheet with axis the xx-axis.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

(d) This is a circular cone centred on the yy-axis.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

(e) This is an ellipsoid centered on the origin with semiaxes 33, 12=23\sqrt{12}=2\sqrt{3} and 33 along the xx, yy and zz-axes, respectively.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

(f) This is a sphere of radius rb=12b2+4b+97r_b=\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{b^2+4b+97} centered on 12(4,b,9)\frac{1}{2}(-4,b,-9).

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

(g) This is an elliptic paraboloid with axis the xx-axis.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

(h) This is an upward openning parabolic cylinder.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Full solution

(a) For each fixed z0z_0, the z=z0z=z_0 cross-section (parallel to the xyxy-plane) of this surface is an ellipse centered on the origin with one semiaxis of length 2 along the xx-axis and one semiaxis of length 4 along the yy-axis. So this is an elliptic cylinder parallel to the zz-axis. Here is a sketch of the part of the surface above the xyxy–plane.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 735

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 735

(b) This is a plane through (4,0,0)(4,0,0), (0,4,0)(0,4,0) and (0,0,2)(0,0,2). Here is a sketch of the part of the plane in the first octant.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

(c) For each fixed x0x_0, the x=x0x=x_0 cross-section parallel to the yzyz-plane is an ellipse with semiaxes 31+x02163\sqrt{1+\frac{x_0^2}{16}} parallel to the yy-axis and 21+x02162\sqrt{1+\frac{x_0^2}{16}} parallel to the zz-axis. As you move out along the xx-axis, away from x=0x=0, the ellipses grow at a rate proportional to 1+x216\sqrt{1+\frac{x^2}{16}}, which for large xx is approximately x4\frac{|x|}{4}. This is called a hyperboloid of one sheet. Its

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

(d) For each fixed y0y_0, the y=x0y=x_0 cross-section (parallel to the xzxz-plane) is a circle of radius y|y| centred on the yy-axis. When y0=0y_0=0 the radius is 00. As you move further from the xzxz-plane, in either direction, i.e. as y0|y_0| increases, the radius grows linearly. The full surface consists of a bunch of these circles stacked sideways. This is a circular cone centred on the yy-axis.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

(e) This is an ellipsoid centered on the origin with semiaxes 33, 12=23\sqrt{12}=2\sqrt{3} and 33 along the xx, yy and zz-axes, respectively.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 735

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 735

(f) Completing three squares, we have that x2+y2+z2+4xby+9zb=0x^2+y^2+z^2+4x-by+9z-b=0 if and only if $(x+2)^2+\big(y-\frac{b}{2}\big)^2+\big(z+\frac{9}{2}\big)^2 =b+4+\frac{b^2}{4}+\frac{81}{4}$. This is a sphere of radius rb=12b2+4b+97r_b=\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{b^2+4b+97} centered on 12(4,b,9)\frac{1}{2}(-4,b,-9).

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

(g) There are no points on the surface with x<0x<0. For each fixed x0>0x_0>0 the cross-section x=x0x=x_0 parallel to the yzyz-plane is an ellipse centred on the xx–axis with semiaxes x0\sqrt{x_0} in the yy-axis direction and 32x0\frac{3}{2}\sqrt{x_0} in the zz–axis direction. As you increase x0x_0, i.e. move out along the xx-axis, the ellipses grow at a rate proportional to x0\sqrt{x_0}. This is an elliptic paraboloid with axis the xx-axis.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

(h) This is called a parabolic cylinder. For any fixed y0y_0, the
y=y0y=y_0 cross-section (parallel to the xzxz-plane) is the upward opening parabola z=x2z=x^2 which has vertex on the yy-axis.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 673

Q9Stage 2

Sketch the level curves of the function

f(x,y)=sin(x+y)f(x,y)=\sin(x+y)

for z=0z=0, z=1z=1, and z=2z=2.

Hint

To solve (say) sin(x+y)=0\sin(x+y)=0, you get lots of solutions: x+y=0x+y=0, x+y=πx+y=\pi, x+y=2πx+y=2\pi, etc.

Answer

z=0z=0:

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 3

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 3

z=1z=1:

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 15

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 15

z=2z=2:

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 28

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 28

Full solution

The level curves of z=0z=0 correspond to all points (x,y)(x,y) such that 0=sin(x+y)0=\sin(x+y). The angles that make sinθ\sin \theta equal to 0 are θ=πn\theta = \pi n for integer values of nn. So, the level curves are lines of the form

x+y=πnx+y=\pi n

where nn is any integer.

So, our level curve has the lines y=xy=-x, y=πxy=\pi-x, y=2πxy=2\pi-x, etc.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 3

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 3

The level curves of z=1z=1 correspond to all points (x,y)(x,y) such that 1=sin(x+y)1=\sin(x+y). The angles that make sinθ\sin \theta equal to 1 are θ=pi2+2πn\theta =\frac{pi}{2}+ 2\pi n for integer values of nn. So, the level curves are lines of the form

x+y=π2+2πnx+y=\frac{\pi}{2}+2\pi n

where nn is any integer.

So, our level curve has the lines y=π2xy=\frac{\pi}{2}-x, y=π2+2πxy=\frac{\pi}{2}+2\pi-x, y=π2+4πxy=\frac{\pi}{2}+4\pi-x, etc.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 15

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 15

The equation 2=sin(x+y)2=\sin(x+y) has no solutions, since no angle has sine greater than 1. So the level curve at z=2z=2 has no points:

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 28

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 28

Stage 3 · Application

Q10Stage 3

The surface below has circular level curves, centred along the zz-axis. The lines given are the intersection of the surface with the right half of the yzyz-plane. Give an equation for the surface.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 2

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 2

Hint

Since the level curves are circles centred at the origin (in the xyxy-plane), the equation will have the form x2+y2=g(z)x^2+y^2=g(z), where g(z)g(z) is a function depending only on zz.

Answer

x2+y2=(z3+1)2\displaystyle x^2+y^2=\left( \frac{|z|}{3}+1\right)^2

Full solution

Since the level curves are circles centred at the origin (in the xyxy-plane), when zz is a constant, the equation will have the form x2+y2=cx^2+y^2=c for some constant. That is, our equation looks like

x2+y2=g(z),x^2+y^2=g(z),

where g(z)g(z) is a function depending only on zz.

Because our cross-sections are so nicely symmetric, we know the intersection of the figure with the left side of the yzyz-plane as well: z=3(y1)=3(y+1)z=3(-y-1)=-3(y+1) (when z0z\ge0) and z=3(y1)=3(y+1)z=-3(-y-1)=3(y+1) (when z<0z<0). Below is the intersection of our surface with the yzyz plane.

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 2

Figure from prac_s1.5, line 2

Setting x=0x=0, our equation becomes y2=g(z)y^2=g(z). Looking at the right side of the yzyz plane, this should lead to: $\left.\begin{cases} z=3(y-1) &\text{if } z\geq 0,\ y\ge 1\ z=-3(y-1) &\text{if } z< 0,\ y\ge 1 \end{cases}\right}$. That is:

z=3(y1)z3+1=y(z3+1)2=y2()\begin{align*} |z|&=3(y-1)\\ \frac{|z|}{3}+1&=y\\ \left(\frac{|z|}{3}+1\right)^2&=y^2 &(*) \end{align*}

A quick check: when we squared both sides of the equation in ()(*), we added another solution, z3+1=y\frac{|z|}{3}+1=-y. Let's make sure we haven't diverged from our diagram.

(z3+1)2=y2z3+1positive=±y{z3+1=yy>0z3+1=yy<0[0]{z3+1=yy1z3+1=yy1[0]{z=3(y1)y1z=3(y+1)y1[0]{z=±3(y1)positivey1z=±3(y+1)negativey1[0]{z=3(y1)y1, z0z=3(y1)y1, z0z=3(y+1)y1, z0z=3(y+1)y1, z0\begin{align*} &&& \left(\frac{|z|}{3}+1\right)^2=y^2\\ &\Leftrightarrow&& \underbrace{\frac{|z|}{3}+1}_{\text{positive}}=\pm y\\ &\Leftrightarrow&& \begin{cases} \frac{|z|}{3}+1 =y & y>0\\[0.05in] \frac{|z|}{3}+1 =-y & y<0 \end{cases}[0]\\[0.1in] & \Leftrightarrow&& \begin{cases} \frac{|z|}{3}+1 =y & y\ge1\\[0.05in] \frac{|z|}{3}+1 =-y & y\le-1 \end{cases}[0]\\[0.1in] &\Leftrightarrow&& \begin{cases} |z| =3(y-1) & y\ge1\\[0.05in] |z|=-3(y+1) & y\le-1 \end{cases}[0]\\[0.1in] &\Leftrightarrow&& \begin{cases} z =\pm \underbrace{3(y-1)}_{\text{positive}} & y\ge1\\ z=\pm \underbrace{3(y+1)}_{\text{negative}} & y\le-1 \end{cases}[0]\\[0.1in] &\Leftrightarrow&& \begin{cases} z =3(y-1) & y\ge1,\ z\ge0\\ z =-3(y-1) & y\ge1,\ z\le0\\ z=-3(y+1) & y\le-1,\ z \ge 0\\ z=3(y+1) & y\le-1,\ z\le 0 \end{cases} \end{align*}

This matches our diagram eactly. So, all together, the equation of the surface is

x2+y2=(z3+1)2x^2+y^2=\left( \frac{|z|}{3}+1\right)^2

From the UBC Math 100 open textbook project, © Joel Feldman, Andrew Rechnitzer, Elyse Yeager and others. Licensed CC BY-NC-SA 4.0; this HTML adaptation is released under the same licence. Full attribution.